Le commentaire final pour Gamervision (9/10) me parait d´assez bonne augure :
The game is the closest to perfection in the history of the Mario franchise, but it is still a Mario title. Mario games are wonderful and full of whimsy but this doesn´t break far enough from the old ones to really be considered a 10. Some small issues with the camera keep it from perfection as well, but this is about as close as any platformer will get. It does what Super Mario Brothers did for the NES and what Super Mario 64 did for the N64. Here it is, folks, this is the reason the Wii was made. Enjoy it when it hits shelves on November 12th in America.
Le meilleur de la série, la quasi-perection dans son domaine, l´équivalent de Mario Bros. et de Mario 64 à leurs époques, c´est à cause de quelques angles de caméra défectueux et du manque de rupture avec le reste de la série que le 10 lui échappe. Rien que ça.
Bien entendu, celui de Deeko est encore plus radical :
So, are there any problems with Galaxy or aspects that I didn´t like? Well, no. I tried very hard to find a flaw of any sort and there was nothing really game breaking. Any complaints I have with the game, well, they´re so minute that I can´t even remember them at this point. That or they just don´t exist. It´s rare to play through a perfect game or one that nears perfection, but Galaxy definitely fits that mold.
D´après ces premiers résultats, je prévois 10/10 sur le magazine officiel, environ 19/20 sur JV.com, et maximum 4/10 sur Gamerama.